Sunday, 26 May 2013

GlossyBox vs BirchBox - Which Is The Best?!

For a while now I have been thinking about restarting my subscription to a monthly beauty box...I used to subscribe to Glossy Box and She Said Beauty but after a while I felt like I was always getting the same things over and over again, so I cancelled my subscriptions.

I was disappointed to find that She Said Beauty are no longer running their Beauty Box as theirs was my favourite one, so I was left with a dilemma.....

Which beauty box to subscribe to?!
I decided to give both GlossyBox and BirchBox a try on a trial basis for a couple of months, and pick a winner at the end....

So let's see how they did against each other!!!


Birchbox's outer packing is hot pink with the Birchbox name along the outside edge...

Inside is another cardboard box with hot pink edging and the Birchbox emblem on the front...

Inside is a little hot pink nylon drawstring bag....

Containing the products!....

This months box contained:

Mini box of Lindt chocolates
Laura Geller eyeliner (Full Size)
TINY sample of Molton Brown Valbonne perfume
Small sample of La Sultane De Saba Body Lotion
TEENY WEENY sample of Yu-Be moisturiser
BeautyBlender Sponge and BeautyBlender Cleanser (Full Size Sponge) my opinion this box was a massive let down. Ok the BeautyBlender was interesting, and I MAY have liked the Laura Geller liner in a more mainstream colour (mine was purple!) but everything else was boring - and the samples were FAR too miniscule for me to gain any idea of whether or not I liked them! Plus a body lotion and a moisturiser in one box?! Too similar if you ask me!!!

Glossybox's box was a limited edition Pearl Lowe collection, and so the box was designed differently than usual with this lovely floral pattern....Pretty!

Inside we received:

Model co Cheek & Lip Stain - Full Size
SunSense Daily Face Tinted Sunscreen
Nip + Fab Pistachio Sundae Body Butter
Essie Nail Varnish - Full Size
Yves Rocher So Elixir Perfume Sample

Two good full size products here that I will actually get use out of it, will definitely use the Essie and the Model Co products - good mix of other products. 

Which Box Wins?

This month - Glossybox has it for me.

The products excite me more, the brands are much more ones I would go for and I think the sample sizes are much more workable! Birchbox's sample sizes were an absolute joke this month!!!!


This month is Glossy Box's 2nd Birthday - so to celebrate we have some lovely 2nd Birthday paper and a sticker inside! Festive! Though no balloon like we got for their first birthday box...bit disappointed by that if I'm honest!!! lol.

Whats In The Box?!

Stone Beauty Body Lotion Sample - boring.
Headline Colours Nail Varnish 
Beautiful Movements Prime & Create Mixing Medium - tiny sample!
La Roche Posay - Sun Protection Gel - Full Size
Jelly Pong Pong Fairy Lashes Mascara - Full Size
Plus to celebrate their birthday we were given a pack of mini nail files.....cute!

As for Birchbox this month, the packaging remains the same as ever...inside we find:

Weleda Skin Food Sample - decent size
La Societe Parisienne De Savons Soap - Full Size
Mirenesse Perfect Kiss Lipstick Pencil - Full Size
Green & Spring relaxing shampoo - sample size
Gerda Spillman Renaissance Age Serum - tiny sample size
Pocket Mirror

Which Box Wins?!

Well I was more impressed with Birchbox this month than last - the soap is lovely and I will certainly use the lipstick pencil. However the shampoo sample is too small for me to get a good idea of whether or not I like it as I have very long hair and this would barely be enough for one use for me, and the age serum sample size is ridiculously tiny!
I LOVE Jelly Pong Pong so the mascara clinched it for Glossybox this month - I also think the inclusion of a nail varnish can only ever be a good thing.

So who did I cancel my subscription with?

I'm afraid it had to be Birchbox! The tiny samples just didn't do it for me - Glossybox may not always be perfect, but I find their sample sizes much more generous than Birchboxes and when I try a product I at least want enough of it for one decent use!!!!

So...I'm a Glossybox Girl for the foreseeable future!

Do you subscribe to a beauty box? if so, which one and why? if not, would you consider it?
As always, I'd love to hear from you!


  1. Hi Hayley,
    This was such an interesting read for me as I don't subscribe to any beauty boxes and never have. I've been interested to know which is the best because there does seem to be so many 'boxes' around nowadays.
    From what I've read in your post it does seem that Glossybox seems better. Birchbox products seem too small!
    Alex x
    Bump to Baby

  2. Whoop I am loving my GB at the minute xx

  3. I get Birchbox, there have been a couple of occasions where I've been peed off with my box but on the whole I love it xx

  4. I was really impressed with the Glossy Box I got sent to try in March! The two Birchboxes that you got did seem a bit rubbish xx

    Beauty by Emma - Beauty, Mummy & Lifestyle Blog

  5. I had two months of Birch Box and was also disappointed in the end! Aprils had some good items and it was my first beauty box so I didn't really know what to expect. May was a total let down, apart from the lipstick pencil you mentioned. Think I might try out Glossy instead x

  6. I used to LOVE GB but recently theyve been a bit crap. Sometimes its such a disappointment. Unless your editor in chief to Vogue then you get all the bad colours and samples of things! :(


What are your thoughts on this post? Please leave a comment!

If you have any questions please do not hesitate to e-mail me at or tweet me @sparkles_blog

Blogger Template by pipdig